When we tamp, we’re not trying to recreate the pressure the basket will receive from the espresso machine. Espresso is normally extracted using nine bar of pressure, delivered via the pump connected with the machine. This is equal to approximately 60 kgs of force per inch2. Considering an average basket (58ml) is approximately 4 inch2, that equals a full metric butt-load of pressure pushing down on our beautifully tamped coffee. As an average human, I cannot match that, so in all seriousness, I’m not going to even try.
Instead, we’re using pressure when we tamp to make our coffee even and reduce those spaces between the grinds before they’re exposed to that pressurised water. However, the old wisdom passed down to us through the coffee ages has traditionally been: If your coffee is pouring too fast, tamp harder and vice-versa.
But does the pressure we tamp with really affect our shot times? Recently, I set myself a little experiment: Using the same dose weights and grind settings, how much variance could I get in my shot times through adjusting my tamp pressure alone?
The results? Over 30+ baskets, there was no more than 4-5 seconds difference — no matter how hard or soft I tamped. (For the record, not tamping at all had every second or third shot Channel really badly.)
The easiest way to approach tamping pressure is this: Ensuring that the tamp will be level when pressure is applied, only push down hard enough so, if the basket is inverted, the coffee doesn’t fall out. That’s all you need.
Any softer and you’ll see Channelling, any harder and you’ll suffer the ‘Barista wrist’, sore neck and sore back from trying to ‘force’ the coffee all day. It’s pretty simple: tamp with a straight wrist and don’t go too hard.